Identity Task 2: Critique

Albert Einstein – Yousuf Karsh

Of all of Karsh’s artworks, the Albert Einstein photograph (1948) is among my favorite of his.

CONTENT

Einstein is shown at a calm and quiet moment. His hands are folded and resting forward as he sits. His famously unmanageable white hair and wool sweater add to his identity of being modest and friendliness. The scene is set with a neutral, dark background that draws all eyes to Einstein. His posture is relaxed but respectable, and his expression conveys wisdom and deep thought. This picture captures the other side of a man who is frequently seen as a representation of intelligence.

 

STYLE & GENRE

The photograph has a lot of contrast and is in black and white. Texture is emphasized by Karsh’s use of color, particularly in Einstein’s face and sweater. Soft lighting and a sense of stillness characterize the timeless and classic style. Because of its natural, human tone, it avoids rigidity while leaning toward traditional formal portraiture.

 

PHOTOGRAPHIC ATTRIBUTES

Karsh shoots from eye level, creating a sense of equality and closeness between the viewer and Einstein. Einstein’s face and hands, which are the brightest areas of the picture, are softly lighted, grabbing the viewer’s attention right away. The background disappears, keeping the subject in focus. Particularly in Einstein’s sweater and hair, there are detailed textures and gentle shadows. The viewer’s attention is drawn to emotion and expression by the lines’ simplicity and absence of distractions or the presence of other mixed elements.

 

MEANING/INTENT

The atmosphere is warm and reflective. Karsh aimed to portray Einstein as a kind person rather than as a distant genius. That objective is supported by minimal styling, posture, and lighting. I’m motivated by this picture to emphasize the truth over perfection in my own portraits by using lighting and expression to highlight emotional depth.

Identity Task 1: Inspiration

Yousuf Karsh: Name of my chosen artist as my inspiration. The goal of Yousuf Karsh’s artwork is to capture the personality and soul of his subjects, who often include famous people like Audrey Hepburn, Winston Churchill, and Albert Einstein. He was interested in expressing something deeper than appearances, such as strength, danger, confidence, or wisdom. Karsh created his portraits during the 20th century, a period marked by significant world events, and they came to represent humanity, power, and influence.

Karsh is known for his dramatic and bright style. He frequently created the face using a single light source, producing striking light-shadow contrasts (chiaroscuro effect). His compositions are typically straightforward and organized; subjects are typically posed, facing the camera or slightly off of it, some making intense eye contact, and intending small body movements. He preferred white and neutral backgrounds that let the subject take center stage or slightly off from the middle but still portray it as the focused object.

I chose Karsh as my artist because his portraits are bold and seem deep. They inspire me to look into the ways that posture and expression may express strong hidden messages and how light and shadow can influence mood. In my own work, I want to try out stilled poses, brightly colored lighting, and simple backgrounds. In my portraits, I want to explore his ability to get a personal response in finding the extraordinary in the ordinary.

 

Four Images:

Winston Churchill – Yousuf Karsh

The first image is the famous Winston Churchill, taken in 1941.

  • Bold and sharp lighting, contrast in the person’s upper body
  • Posture indicates power and resilience by portraying a serious mood.

 

Albert Einstein – Yousuf Karsh

The second image is Albert Einstein in 1948.

  • Soft lighting; emphasizing the subject’s age and wisdom
  • Hands folding calmly
  • Background fades to black
  • Unlike Churchill, Einstein’s portrait feels quiet. It shows Karsh’s ability to adapt lighting and tone to match the subject’s personality.

 

Ernest Hemingway – Yousuf Karsh

Third photo: Ernest Hemingway, 1957

  • Contrasted lights; displaying his rugged personality
  • Closed-up crop, indicating details and the focus point
  • Looking away from the camera (maybe a technique I want to try)
  • This portrait shows how Karsh used light, texture, and body language to suggest emotion without needing a dramatic pose.

 

Georgia O'Keeffe – Yousuf Karsh

Fourth photo: Georgia O’Keeffe, 1956

  • Soft light around her face, coming from the window
  • Partially in black (bottom half of the photo), and partially whiter (top half)
  • Expression is neutral, calm, and instant
  • This portrait includes techniques in contrast and form in a way that makes the subject feel timeless, almost sculptural—perfect for an artist like O’Keeffe.